RE : chord function (aguas de marco)

Pedro Batista ( PBATISTA@colep.mailpac.pt )
1 Jul 97 10:19 GMT

[Reed]
> It does help you play over the tune to recognize these minor plagal
> cadence situations because you know not to alter the dominant 9,5,13
> notes.
> You know to use the appropriate jazz minor scale.
[Marc Sabatella ]
> Until you pointed out that this is what was going on, I always wondered
> what the deal was with these resolutions; now they make much more sense to
> me. I always tended to use the #11 in such situations (which is precisely
> the scale you recommend), but never knew why this sounded best. On the
> other hand, the altered ninths are pretty strong too - the flat ninth
> becomes the major seventh of the next chord, and the sharp ninth resolves
> down a half step to the root of the next chord.

As I've said, before (I've been told this is covered by Levine's theory
book, but I'm still waiting for mine to arrive), this all has to do with the
melodic minor. As there are no avoid notes on this scale, you can use
virtualy any of its modes in substitution of any other. They are
interchangeable.
Relevant modes may be :
I m (6, maj7,9,11) - melodic or jazz minor
bIII maj7/6 (#5,9, #11) - lydian with #5
IV 7 (9,#11,13) - lydian dominant
VI m7 (b5,9,11,b13) - locrian with maj9
VII 7 (b5/#5, b9/#9) or VII 7 alt - altered dominant

For instance when you have a minor 6th chord as in a plagal cadence, you can
subs it by a 7(#11) - lydian dominant - a perfect fourth above
(correspondance between the I and IV degrees). An altered 7 by a m6 half
step above (between VII and I). A m7(b5) can be replaced by m6 a major 6th
below (between I and VI) etc.
The improvisation scale is allways the melodic minor of the respective I
(one).

Notice, that even the tritone sub is present between the VII and the IV, and
is this correspondance to the IV that imo is responsible for the statement
that the scale of the subV7 is the lydian dominant scale, with a #11!
In the particular case of plagal Em6 substituted for A(9,#11,13) thats why
other extensions/alterations of the A7 won't work (they would go outside the
melodic E scale, thus making the substitution invalid).
Pedro