Re: Levine and dominant resolutions

reed ( (no email) )
Fri, 11 Jul 1997 12:26:54 -0700

David
<<snip>>
>On a related note, I also thought is was strange to analyze the bridge of
>What is this thing... by calling the Ab7 a tritone sub for D7. Was the
>original change D7 and the be-boppers put in Ab7? Even in the Sinatra
>arrangement I have heard they are playing Ab7, which leads me to believe
>that that was the original change. Was Cole Porter using the tritone sub
>almost fifteen years before the be-boppers? I tend to agree with Roger
>McDuffie that it is Aug6 resolution.
>
Well certainly be-boppers didnt invent tri-tone subsitutions.

I think Bach knew about them and certainly Chopin used them everywhere.

In this situation, I can see the point of seeing the Ab7 as essentially
a bVI7 in C (which is a borrowed chord from C [harmonic] minor).

So essentially then we have bVI7->V7->ivm->I with some appropriate
approach chords.

A similar move occurs in the beginning of "Well Be Together Again".

<snip>>
>
>In the edited discussion of Stella, reed says
>
>>In fact despite all this, the Emi7b7 to A7 still functions as a
>>Dbdim7 chord which naturally can move to Cmi7, which is the next
>>chord.
>
>Actually, Cm7 is one of four chords I would expect to not come after
>Dbdim7, since it is neither a viidim7 of C nor an irregular resolution
>(Cdim to Cm). It works in Someday My Prince as a passing chord, but in
>Stella it must be doing something else.
>

Your snippet is somewhat removed from the larger context of what
I was explaining (The Dbdim7 chord is more strongly analyzed as
Bbdim7 with the whole first 8 bars being a sort of delayed resoltuion of
Bbdim7->Bb) but in any case ....

That chord progression (biiidim7 -> iim7->V7 ...)doesnt occur in classical
music but it occurs not too infrequently in american popular music.

The most famous example is the beginning of "Embraceable You" by
Gershwin.

I -> biiidim7 -> iim7 -> V7.

reed

Reed Kotler
reed@justjazz.com
http://www.justjazz.com