Re: guitar/piano question

Brent Burleigh ( Brent_Burleigh@MBnet.MB.CA )
Thu, 13 Feb 1997 08:12:33 -0600 (CST)

>Bert Ligon wrote:
>>
>> "tacet." Edward took this to be rude and I can see how he would feel
that
>>
>> The advantage a pianist has is that he can accompany himself without
any
>> support, bass, guitar or drums. If the pianist is adventurous at all
with
>> the harmony during his solo, only a mind reader could make consistent
>> choices to accompany him on guitar.
>>
>> The guitarist has to
>> consider that an amplified guitar can quickly overpower a piano. Simple
>> I have played with guitarist where there was never a problem, in
any
>> style, and others where it was always a problem.
>
> pianists invariably comp for the
>other soloists, comp for me, and comp for themselves. This doesn't leave
>me much to do when I'm not soloing. When I'm soloing I've got very good
>command of harmony and subs, so I don't *need* someone comping,
>especially if they aren't paying attention to where I'm going.
>
>Clay

I have been studying jazz guitar for about 4 1/2 years with my guitar
teacher, and for 4 1/2 years he's said, "Volume Separation". The
idea is very important, especially if you're playing around with #9s and
building it, or getting diminished qualities, etc.

If you're the soloist, get yourself oodles of command. Demand that your
instrument controls the volume. If you listen to a well recorded song
with a good vocalist, that vocalist is filling up half the dynamic range
of the recording. You should have just as much control. If the chord
man is playing a dom. seventh and you want that #9 sound, you play the
#9, if you're louder, you win. If he's not listening, you'll sound good,
he'll sound bad (we hope).

I think I would be unable to stand playing with someone who is doing less
than trying to make me sound great. The show is for the audience. If
you're the soloist, that song should revolve around you. If there are
politics, I think I can make whomever sound really lame in return.
But what will the audience think. If he's not paying you, get rid of
the guy.

Tacet is undoubtedly MAXIMUM volume separation! If you decide to take
a song in a different direction than practiced, or a new undeniable urge
possesses your horn, jazz is freedom. Louder is better.

)-(ammerhands
Brent_Burleigh@mbnet.mb.ca
Student of the Six-String Abacus